Loading...

03 Jul 2026 16:52

Editor's Pick Advertising & Marketing Experiential Marketing Recommended for You The Latest

Trust, Creativity and Accountability Take Centre Stage at Goafest 2026 Day 3

Trust, Creativity and Accountability Take Centre Stage at Goafest 2026 Day 3

Day 3 of Goafest 2026 set the stage for yet another promising day filled with powerful industry conversations, thought leadership, and future-focused insights. The day commenced with an interesting session titled ‘The Client Who Also Became the Agency’, powered by Hindustan Times. The panel featured Raj Kamble, Founder & CCO, Famous Innovations; Gaurav Ramdev, CMO – India & South Asia, Visa; Ajay Kakar, Head – Corporate Branding, Adani Group; Chandan Mendiratta, Chief Brand Officer, Zepto; and Harsh Deep Chhabra, Global Head – Media, Godrej Consumer Products Limited. The discussion was moderated by Rohit Ohri, Founder, Ohriginal. The session explored the rise of in-house creativity, the changing role of agencies, and how brands are increasingly seeking agile, collaborative, and culturally relevant creative solutions.

Raj Kamble, Founder & CCO, Famous Innovations, enlightened on the role of culture and creative tension in driving better work between brands and agencies. He said, “The biggest difference between agencies and in-house teams is culture. Agencies bring outside perspective, debate, challenge and creative friction, while many brands build in-house teams for cost efficiency and tighter control. Creative excellence thrives when brands and agencies work as true partners, and strong agency culture encourages disagreement, experimentation, and bold thinking.”

Highlighting how modern marketing models are evolving towards agility, culture-led responsiveness, and hybrid operating structures, Gaurav Ramdev, CMO – India & South Asia, Visa, said, “In-housing is driven by the need for speed, agility, and cultural relevance, as modern brands must react to culture and consumer behaviour in real time. Long-term strategic campaigns and fast-moving daily content now coexist together, while consistency at scale remains critical alongside local adaptation and rapid trend response. The future operating model will be a hybrid between traditional agencies and agile in-house systems.”

Speaking on the evolving nature of brand-agency partnerships and the need for greater collaboration and relevance, Ajay Kakar, Head – Corporate Branding, Adani Group, said, “The relationship between brands and agencies should function like a strong partnership built on mutual value. Brands move work in-house when agencies fail to meet expectations around speed, relevance, or execution, while the industry must focus more on conversations and audience relevance than only impressions and reach. The future depends on transparent collaboration, evolving with new tools and technologies, and building complementary strengths.”

Chandan Mendiratta, Chief Brand Officer, Zepto, emphasized Zepto’s in-house marketing model as a driver of speed, cultural relevance, and consistency. He said, “Zepto’s in-house model is built for agility and real-time cultural relevance, where social media comments and consumer behaviour inspire campaigns within minutes. The brand operates like a content creator brand, celebrating multiple cultural moments and micro-occasions through highly frequent, trend-driven campaigns. Brand culture cannot be outsourced, and in-house teams help maintain consistency across design, PR, communication, and branding.”

Emerging on how media scale, in-housing, and business alignment have reshaped marketing effectiveness, Harsh Deep Chhabra, Global Head – Media, Godrej Consumer Products Limited, added, “Godrej Consumer Products scaled from being among the top 20 advertisers to one of India’s top 4 advertisers, with campaigns increasing from around 10 to nearly 30 per month. In housing became critical as business data, growth KPIs, and strategic insights are deeply integrated internally. The focus is not on awards, but on marketplace growth, brand visibility, shareholder value, and aligning marketing efforts closely with business outcomes and sales impact.”

This was followed by a session presented by LinkedIn titled ‘The Great Attention Reset: Because Growth Today Is Built on Trust, Not Traffic’. The discussion featured Punit Dharamsi, Executive Vice President, Association of Mutual Funds in India (AMFI); Tuhina Pandey, Director, APAC Communications & Chief Marketing Officer, India and South Asia, IBM; and Jahid Ahmed, Senior Vice President and Head of Digital, HDFC Bank. The session was moderated by Devajit Roy, Head of India, Mid Market & Growth – Marketing Solutions, LinkedIn. The speakers discussed how brands today must prioritise authenticity, credibility, and meaningful engagement over short-term traffic metrics to build sustainable long-term growth.

Trust, Creativity and Accountability Take Centre Stage at Goafest 2026 Day 3

Punit Dharamsi, Executive Vice President, Association of Mutual Funds in India (AMFI), spoke about the importance of life-stage-led financial communication and trust-building in investor education. He said, “Financial communication works best during key life moments like first jobs, marriage, childbirth, retirement, increments, and tax planning. AMFI focuses on contextual messaging around financial milestones, encouraging young earners to begin SIPs with their first salary. Through continuous, always-on communication, educational content formats, and character- led storytelling, the emphasis remains on investor education and trust-building over panic during market volatility.”

Talking about the growing importance of relevance-led communication in complex B2B decision environments, Tuhina Pandey, Director, APAC Communications & Chief Marketing Officer, India and South Asia, IBM, highlighted that, “Relevance matters more than reach in today’s attention economy, especially when influencing modern buying committees across CMOs, CFOs, CEOs, and CIOs. AI is becoming both an audience and an intermediary, changing how relevance is measured. Strong storytelling, aligned sequencing, and smart repurposing across short- and long-form content help drive engagement across the funnel, with effectiveness ultimately tied to business journeys and pipeline impact.”

Jahid Ahmed, Senior Vice President and Head of Digital, HDFC Bank, called out his views strongly on the shift in digital marketing towards trust-driven and intent-led ecosystems. “Attention today is built on trust, safety, relevance, and frictionless experiences. Marketing is shifting from interruption- led communication to intent-led ecosystems, where credibility matters more than reach. Creator partnerships, peer validation, and educational content are driving both awareness and conversion, while first-party data and personalisation at scale are becoming central to building long-term trust and improving customer lifetime value,” he emphasized.

The conversations then shifted towards measurement and accountability with ‘From Platform- Defined to Brand-Aligned: A Reset in Measurement’, powered by Mediakart & Times Network. The panel featured Aditi Mishra, Chief Executive Officer, Lodestar; Dhiraj Gupta, Co-Founder & Chief Technology Officer, mFilterIt; Neha Markanda, Chief Business Officer, ShareChat; and Shahad Anand, Business Head, Mediakart. The discussion was moderated by Ashish Sehgal, Chief Executive Officer – Times TV Network & CGO – Times Media & Entertainment.

Talking about the limitations of relying solely on platform-driven metrics in brand building, Aditi Mishra, Chief Executive Officer, Lodestar, added, “Platform metrics should be treated as tools, not the final measure of brand success, since performance data alone cannot define long-term growth. Brands must balance data with instinct and consumer understanding, as there is no single source of truth in measurement today. Ultimately, consumers buy products, not algorithms, and strong brand building requires contextual storytelling, emotional connection, and collaboration across agencies, marketers, and multiple measurement frameworks.”

Trust, Creativity and Accountability Take Centre Stage at Goafest 2026 Day 3

Underscoring the importance of independent validation in advertising measurement, Dhiraj Gupta, Co-Founder & Chief Technology Officer, mFilterIt, added, “Measurement in advertising is ultimately about trust and validating platform claims, which is why independent third-party verification is essential instead of relying only on platform-defined metrics. Advertisers need proof of audience quality and delivery, and measurement must support business outcomes and shareholder value. As the saying goes, ‘the maker cannot be the checker, and the checker cannot be the maker,’ making transparency and accountability non-negotiable in building advertiser confidence.”

Neha Markanda, Chief Business Officer, ShareChat, further emphasized the need for platform- agnostic thinking and culturally grounded measurement. “Platforms should act as partners aligned with brand objectives, where different platforms solve different business use cases and cannot fulfil every objective equally. User participation, culture, and context matter as much as impressions, and brands must triangulate platform data, user behaviour, and business outcomes rather than rely on a single metric. Ultimately, success is reflected when ‘user truth’ and ‘brand truth’ align through engagement, sales, and meaningful cultural relevance beyond demographics,” she added.

Talking about the importance of keeping measurement tied to real business impact rather than treating it as the end goal, Shahad Anand, Business Head, Mediakart, said, “Brands focus on efficiency, money and growth, where measurement exists to support business objectives rather than become the objective itself. Metrics like CAC, ROAS and conversions matter only when they drive real outcomes, as brand building, acquisition and sales each require different approaches. In an environment where every piece of content can be monetised, trusted third-party verification is critical to ensure transparency and validate whether campaigns are creating real behavioural impact.”

Another major highlight of the morning was ‘Scale vs Soul: Creativity in the Age of Agency Consolidation’, powered by CNN News18. The conversation featured Ashish Chakravarty, Managing Partner & CCO, Garage Worldwide; Ashish Khazanchi, Managing Partner, Enormous; Senthil Kumar, Storyteller & Film Director; and Tarun Bhagat, Chief Marketing Officer, PepsiCo. The session was moderated by Delshad Irani, Storyboard, Network18 Group.

Ashish Chakravarty, Managing Partner & CCO, Garage Worldwide, highlighted the changing dynamics between agency models and modern marketing expectations. “Legacy agencies and independent setups operate with different pressures, where larger networks often follow global processes while independent agencies build distinct creative cultures. CMOs today are more aware and proactive, increasingly asking for disruptive, culturally relevant work that drives fame, visibility, and cultural impact, making communication not just operational but a core driver of conversation and culture,” Ashish said.

Trust, Creativity and Accountability Take Centre Stage at Goafest 2026 Day 3

Highlighting the tension between scale and creativity in the industry, Ashish Khazanchi, Managing Partner & CCO, Garage Worldwide, said, “Independent agencies are not the only ones creating impactful work—large networks also produce strong campaigns. But sustaining scale often shifts focus towards numbers, efficiency, and targets, where Excel-driven pressures can dilute creative freedom. While the industry is becoming more performance-oriented, brands and CMOs still want work that makes them famous, enters culture, and sometimes requires the courage to say ‘no’ to preserve creative integrity.”

Talking about the role of strong brand-led thinking in creativity, Senthil Kumar, Storyteller & Film Director, added, “Brand ideas build brands while creative ideas come from creative souls, and strong creativity must amplify a central brand idea through persistence and belief. AI is a tool that can improve execution efficiency and reduce production costs, but it lacks emotional depth. It cannot replace human storytelling, which remains defined by characters, individuality, and emotional resonance.”

Emphasizing the point, highlighting a growing industry reality, Tarun Bhagat, Chief Marketing Officer, PepsiCo, said, “The debate between large and small agencies is often overrated, as great work ultimately depends on people rather than agency size. Consumers remember impactful campaigns, not structures, while brands continue to seek long-term growth, consistency, and legacy alongside faster, culturally relevant ideas. CMOs are increasingly open to bold thinking, but what ultimately matters is delivering emotionally impactful work that strengthens the brand over time.”

In addition to the keynote sessions and panel discussions, Day 3 also featured a keynote on Micro and Macro Resets Across Marketing, Advertising and Media by Rana Barua, Group CEO, Havas India, SE Asia and North Asia (Japan and South Korea). Addressing the quorum, Rana said, “The marketing, advertising and media industry is undergoing a positive reset driven by evolving consumer behaviour, changing media habits and rapid technological progress. AI is no longer just a discussion point but an integral part of business, creativity, and everyday workflows, enabling smarter productivity and decision-making. Agencies are evolving into integrated business and communication partners, while the future belongs to adaptable super specialists who combine deep expertise with broader business understanding.”

Furthermore, masterclasses offered delegates deeper perspectives on audio storytelling, social-first branding, cultural ownership, consumer behaviour, and omni-channel marketing strategies.Spotify Advertising’s masterclass titled ‘Make It Heard: Designing Ideas for the Sound-On Generation on Spotify’, was led by Haran Ramachandaran, Head of Creative Lab, JAPAC; Akshita Kolluru, Creative Strategist, India; and Shraddha Shetty, Creative Strategist, India. White Rivers Media conducted a masterclass titled ‘Gen Z in the Era of Social 3.0: A Playbook for Building Brands That Belong on Social’, led by Mitesh Kothari, Co-Founder & Chief Creative Officer. The Insider Media’s masterclass ‘The IP Masterclass: Don’t Just Sponsor Culture, Own It’, was led by Ansh Agarwal, Founder and CEO, Insider Media. YouTube’s masterclass titled ‘Captivate to Convert: Mastering YouTube’s High- Impact Engine’, was led by Anurag Pasi, Content Solutions and Sponsorship Lead, YouTube.

Trust, Creativity and Accountability Take Centre Stage at Goafest 2026 Day 3

The Market Research Society of India (MRSI) hosted a masterclass titled ‘The Reset Consumer: Understanding the New Psychology of Choice’ featuring Parameswaran Venkataraman, Co- founder, 3 Big Things, and Prakash Sharma, Behavioural Strategist and Co-Founder, 1001 Stories. The session highlighted how consumers today often get stuck not due to lack of information, but because they are faced with two equally unappealing choices. Through examples from healthcare and smoking cessation, the session explained how decisions shift when a more tangible, believable “third path” is introduced. It also highlighted how rituals, visible progress, and public acknowledgement help reinforce sustained behaviour change. The masterclass delivered a core message – that when outcomes feel real and within control, consumers move from hesitation to action.

PrismX By Mobavenue conducted a masterclass titled ‘Syncing Screens, Scaling Brands: The PrsmX Playbook for Omni-Channel Success’ featuring Saransh Gehlot, Head – Account Management, PrsmX, and Srinath Kotamarju, Head of LCS Advertising and Partnerships. With discussions spanning creativity, trust, media accountability, and the future of brand-agency relationships, the first half of Day 3 reinforced Goafest 2026’s role as a catalyst for industry-defining dialogue and innovation.

The lunch on Day 3 was presented by Dangal TV.

(Visited 60 times, 1 visits today)
peri hokiperihokiduta 76AWSBEThttps://sintnicolaasschool.com/https://abc1131aa.com/kincir88cakar76Slot mahjonghttps://www.abc1131.it.com/Gerakan99Era77stc76duta76duta76 loveduta76 careduta76bduta76 sejiwaduta76 lokasiterdekatduta76 africafuelduta76 oscarmykeduta76 naptimepkduta76 daikinduta76 raes-munichduta76 destyduta76 bio-linkduta76 lynkduta76 heylinkduta76 bioduta76 radarkeduWar138navigasi rtp live eksploitasi peluang taktik mahjong wild deluxe analisa dadu sicbo strategi gates of olympusanalisa komprehensif rtp live pola algoritma strategi mahjong ways 2 pgsoft taktik baccarat teknik starlight princessoptimasi presisi analisa strategi blackjack teknik membaca pola mahjong wins 3 taktik peluang rtp live sweet bonanza pragmaticdekonstruksi peluang taktis strategi analisa roulette pemetaan pola mahjong ways 2 pgsoft teknik membaca rtp live wild west goldeksekusi taktis analisa probabilitas strategi komprehensif sv388 teknik membaca peluang blackjack pola mahjong wins 3 pemetaan rtp live sugar rushstrategi rasional baca rtp live analisa pola gates of olympus taktik sicbo teknik mahjong wild deluxe jitutaktik eksekusi presisi sinkronisasi analisa rtp live pola mahjong ways 2 pgsoft teknik baccarat kuantitatif peluang starlight princesseksploitasi algoritma analisa strategi taktis menaklukkan blackjack pemetaan pola mahjong wins 3 teknik rtp live sweet bonanza pragmaticmetodologi optimasi peluang analisa teknik roulette klasik taktik pola mahjong ways 2 pgsoft strategi rtp live wild west goldanalisa matriks peluang sinkronisasi teknik blackjack taktik sv388 strategi pola rtp live mahjong wins 3 sugar rush pragmatichttps://www.thewayofthespirit.com/contact/kalkulasi taktik cerdas strategi peluang sicbo teknik pola mahjong wild deluxe analisa rtp live gates of olympusdekonstruksi varians strategi pola mahjong ways 2 pgsoft analisa peluang baccarat taktik teknik rtp live starlight princesseksekusi silang taktik teknik strategi blackjack analisa pola mahjong wins 3 pragmatic peluang rtp live sweet bonanzaformulasi taktik peluang roulette analisa pola mahjong ways 2 pgsoft teknik jitu strategi rtp live wild bounty hunternavigasi probabilitas analisa pola mahjong wins 3 pragmatic taktik peluang blackjack strategi sv388 teknik rtp live sugar rushalgoritma menang taktik mahjong wild deluxe peluang sicbo analisa pola gates of olympusanalisa rtp live peluang teknik mahjong ways 2 pgsoft baccarat starlight princessbedah peluang rtp live teknik transisi blackjack sweet bonanza mahjong wins 3 pragmaticeksekusi taktis data peluang roulette teknik wild bounty hunter rtp live mahjong ways 2 pgsoftdekonstruksi multi disiplin strategi blackjack peluang sv388 teknik sugar rush pola mahjong wins 3dekonstruksi peluang jitu analisa pola rtp live gates of olympus sicbo mahjong wild deluxeanalisa kuantitatif taktik peluang baccarat teknik pola mahjong ways 2 pgsoft strategi rtp live starlight princessmetodologi hibrida komprehensif strategi peluang blackjack taktik analisa pola sweet bonanza teknik rtp live mahjong wins 3 pragmaticsinkronisasi algoritma taktik analisa pola mahjong ways 2 pgsoft teknik rtp live wild west gold strategi peluang rouletteanalisa ekosistem komprehensif taktik peluang blackjack sv388 strategi pola teknik rtp live mahjong wins 3 sugar rushmeta taktik hibrida teknik analisa rtp live sicbo mahjong wild deluxe gates of olympustaktik mitigasi risiko analisa pola starlight princess teknik rtp live mahjong ways 2 pgsoft strategi peluang baccarateskalasi taruhan berbasis data analisa pola rtp live mahjong wins 3 pragmatic teknik taktik sweet bonanza strategi peluang blackjackmanajemen volatilitas lanjut analisa teknik pola wild west gold strategi rtp live mahjong ways 2 pgsoft taktik peluang roulettepemetaan volatilitas taktis teknik analisa peluang sv388 blackjack strategi pola rtp live mahjong wins 3 pragmatic sugar rusheksploitasi volatilitas strategi teknik baca pola mahjong wild deluxe sicbo gates of olympuskalibrasi taruhan sistematis strategi peluang baccarat analisa teknik pola rtp live mahjong ways 2 pgsoft starlight princesspemetaan variansi taktis teknik analisa peluang blackjack strategi pola rtp live mahjong wins 3 pragmatic sweet bonanzaoptimasi retensi profit maksimal teknik analisa peluang roulette strategi pola taktik rtp live mahjong ways 2 pgsoft wild west goldkalibrasi probabilitas dinamis taktik peluang blackjack sv388 teknik pola analisa rtp live sugar rush mahjong wins 3analisa silang peluang paten dadu sicbo pola mahjong wild deluxe strategi rtp live gates of olympusintegrasi teknik baccarat analisa pola mahjong ways 2 pgsoft strategi peluang taktik rtp live starlight princesskomparasi algoritma lanjutan sinkronisasi teknik blackjack taktik pola mahjong wins 3 pragmatic analisa strategi peluang rtp live sweet bonanzapemodelan statistik terapan konversi teknik analisa roulette strategi peluang mahjong ways 2 pgsoft taktik pola rtp live wild bounty hunterpemetaan volatilitas algoritmik konversi analisa peluang sv388 strategi teknik mahjong wins 3 taktik pola rtp live sugar rush pragmatictaktik rasional sinkronisasi teknik mahjong wild deluxe dadu sicbo analisa pola pasti gates of olympus terbarumetodologi kuantitatif ekstraksi strategi mahjong ways 2 pgsoft analisa peluang baccarat teknik pola taktik rtp live starlight princesskerangka kerja kuantitatif pragmatic bedah strategi peluang blackjack analisa teknik pola mahjong wins 3 taktik dinamis rtp live sweet bonanzapendekatan algoritma perilaku formulasi taktik peluang roulette strategi teknik mahjong ways 2 pgsoft analisa pola rtp live wild bounty hunterkerangka probabilitas dinamis optimalisasi strategi analisa sv388 taktik peluang mahjong wins 3 pragmatic teknik pola rtp live sugar rushekstraksi peluang mantap teknik dadu sicbo analisa pola jitu mahjong wild deluxe gates of olympuspendekatan statistik terapan strategi baccarat teknik mahjong ways 2 pgsoft analisa pola peluang taktik rtp live starlight princessmetrik validasi taruhan formulasi strategi analisa blackjack teknik peluang mahjong wins 3 pragmatic pemecahan taktik pola rtp live sweet bonanzasintesis taktik multivariabel optimalisasi analisa teknik roulette strategi pola mahjong ways 2 pgsoft peluang rtp live wild bounty hunterintegrasi sistem taruhan terpadu menguji strategi teknik sv388 analisa peluang mahjong wins 3 pragmatic validasi taktik pola rtp live sugar rushdinamika sugar rush mahjong 2 formulasi komputasi peluangformulasi eksperimental sicbo tracking mahjong wild deluxepemetaan skema teknik komparasi sv388 blackjackarsitektur analitik komputasi temporal mahjong ways 2rekayasa model sugar rush kalkulasi probabilitasdinamika simbol premium algoritma probabilitas 2026efisiensi taktis blackjack hit frequency rtpforensik mahjong ways deviasi visual rtpmanajemen risiko dinamis sv388 distribusi rtpmatriks kuantitatif densitas simbol grafik observasiawal kegilaan mahjong wins scatterledakan tempo baru mahjong waysmahjong ways memanas scattter wildmahjong wins berputar berkat kemunculanmahjong wins scatter hitam munculmomentum scatter wild ritme mahjongperubahan arah ritme mahjong waysperubahan drastis mahjong scatter wildportal scatter wild terbuka mahjongscatter hitam datang permainan mahjongscatter hitam pemicu chaos putaranscatter wild alur mahjong cepatscatter wild tempo mahjong agresifsekali muncul scatter wild taktanpa scatter jadi kunci drastise5 pendekatan berbasis data rtpe5 pendekatan sistematis dalam memahamie5 pendekatan sistematis terhadap polae5 peran scatter wild dalame5 perhatikan baik formasi pembukae5 pola bermain modern berawale5 pola pembuka yang seringe5 rahasia pemain lama polae5 rahasia strategi modern berawale5 rtp harian dan evolusisinergi strategi analisa taktik peluang paten rtp live mahjong wild deluxe gates of olympus dadu sicbohibrida strategi analisa probabilitas peluang pola rtp live mahjong ways 2 pgsoft teknik baccarat taktik starlight princessarsitektur kemenangan strategi analisa pola teknik peluang taktik rtp live mahjong wins 3 pragmatic sweet bonanza blackjackdekonstruksi pasti algoritma probabilitas teknik pola rtp live analisa strategi taktik peluang mahjong ways 2 pgsoft roulette wild west goldkuadran eksekusi taktis analisa peluang strategi teknik pola rtp live sv388 blackjack sugar rush mahjong wins 3 pragmaticdekonstruksi peluang unik analisa pola strategi mahjong wild deluxe sicbo gates of olympuskonvergensi teknik taktik strategi peluang asik analisa pola rtp live baccarat mahjong ways 2 pgsoft starlight princessalgoritma ilmu peluang kalibrasi strategi analisa pola taktik teknik rtp live sweet bonanza blackjack mahjong wins 3 pragmaticmanajemen risiko rasionalisasi peluang strategi analisa pola taktik teknik rtp live wild west gold roulette pgsoft mahjong ways 2reverse engineering peluang analisa strategi teknik taktik pola rtp live mahjong wins 3 pragmatic sugar rush blackjack sv388masterclass analisa langka pola teknik rtp live gates of olympus dadu sicbo mahjong wild deluxepemetaan akurat pola analisa strategi taktik teknik peluang rtp live starlight princess baccarat mahjong ways 2 pgsoftmetodologi asing analisa peluang integrasi strategi blackjack taktik pola mahjong wins 3 pragmatic teknik rtp live sweet bonanzasinkronisasi momentum asik analisa taktik strategi roulette teknik pola peluang rtp live mahjong ways 2 pgsoft wild west goldpsikologi kemenangan analisa kognitif taktik strategi teknik peluang pola rtp live mahjong wins 3 blackjack sv388 sugar rushkecenderungan simbol distribusi algoritma komputasional 2026kontrol risiko adaptif probabilitas sistem statistikresonansi variabel pengali probabilistik stabilitas matematisvariabel visual distribusi numerik komputasional pascapembaruanvisual antarsesi kuantitatif grafis statistik observasie5 rtp harian sebagai acuane5 rtp harian sebagai referensie5 satu pola banyak kejutane5 strategi berbasis data evolusie5 strategi cerdas masa kinie5 strategi masa kini berkembange5 strategi modern yang terciptae5 strategi modern ubah datae5 strategi sistematis berbasis datae5 strategi terkini lahir darie5 studi dinamika scatter dane5 studi fitur scatter wilde5 studi interaksi scatter dane5 studi pola visual scattere5 studi struktur simbol scatter Top